Efficient Shared Mail Results Despite a Changing Industry.

Since
Moving Forward
As a result of the new opportunity-ranking approach, Firstleaf reduced their matchback CPAs by over 50%. What the Firstleaf team valued the most, however, was the dialogue, creative thinking, and solution-oriented approach that SLM took to help improve Firstleaf’s direct mail strategy.


Overview
As a leading wine company and subscription service, Firstleaf takes the guesswork out of wine selection, delivering first-class wines directly to customers’ doors.
The Problem
Two years ago, industry headwinds put pressure on Firstleaf’s dual growth priorities - driving efficient returns by balancing low CPAs with high LTVs. As an existing client of Share Local Media, the SLM team heard their feedback and built a customized plan to ensure that Firstleaf saw continued success despite external factors.
Our Solution
SLM took an all-hands approach, gathering multiple internal perspectives and coordinating with Firstleaf’s team to work through the budget, targeting methods, measurement, and creative details. The shared mail team created a opportunity ranking system for market-based mailings that articulated the CPA and LTV tradeoffs of different markets and allowed Firstleaf to easily achieve their goals at different investment levels.
All Case Studies
The Lovery, a digital-first jewelry brand, uses Poplar to send postcards to email subscribers and site visitors who haven’t bought yet. The Lovery’s automated browse and checkout abandonment campaigns have demonstrated the value of re-engaging shoppers.
Customers.ai and Share Local Media partnered with Coop Sleep Goods to turn onsite customer behavior into targeted direct mail campaigns across the customer journey.
Home Chef tested a family-first creative strategy featuring Bluey to see whether more relevant messaging and creative could unlock stronger performance among households with kids.