Injinji Used Direct Mail to Reach the Customers Digital Couldn’t

“Poplar made it easier to get started and keep track of every send, so we’re never over-mailing the customers we’re trying to win back.”
Partners
Since
2025

Moving Forward

Injinji’s winback campaign brought back 203 lapsed customers at a $19.83 cost per order, with a 391% ROAS and a 3.43% response rate.

3.43%
Response Rate
391%
ROAS

Overview

Injinji plans to build more automated retention flows with Klaviyo for more consistent touchpoints. It’s also considering direct mail for new product launches and testing Poplar’s prospecting services to reach new customers.

The Problem

Injinji had a loyal customer base, but a growing share of those customers weren’t responding to email or paid social. The brand needed another way to reach them with new products and promotions before they drifted away for good. A secondary goal was reaching shoppers who had shown interest in Injinji but hadn’t bought yet. Injinji had sent ad hoc mailers before, but without a platform behind them it was hard to track sends or avoid mailing the same people too often.

‍

Our Solution

Injinji moved its direct mail onto Poplar to turn one-off sends into a structured program. The team focused first on retention, launching a winback campaign aimed at lapsed customers who weren’t engaging through digital channels. The postcard led with a 10% off offer and a personalized code to bring them back.Poplar’s Klaviyo segment feature lets Injinji pull audiences straight from Klaviyo, and built-in frequency controls make sure no one gets mailed too often. The team has also started testing retargeting, triggering abandoned cart postcards automatically from its existing Klaviyo flows.

All Case Studies

Injinji
Retention

Injinji partnered with SLM to reach lapsed customers its digital channels weren’t connecting with, using a winback postcard campaign that drove a 391% ROAS and a 3.43% response rate.

The Lovery
Retargeting

The Lovery, a digital-first jewelry brand, uses Poplar to send postcards to email subscribers and site visitors who haven’t bought yet. The Lovery’s automated browse and checkout abandonment campaigns have demonstrated the value of re-engaging shoppers.

Home Chef x Bluey
Prospecting

Home Chef tested a family-first creative strategy featuring Bluey to see whether more relevant messaging and creative could unlock stronger performance among households with kids.

Fabletics
Prospecting

Share Local Media partnered with Fabletics on a OOH activation designed to prove the channel with clear, measurable outcomes.